I just watched it a month ago also....I agree with you that it was like watching a re-run of my own life. It was nice for Coffee Shop Guy to watch the movie with me, since he has never been a JW he got to see on film what I have only described to him (like elders meetings and assemblies)- he truly thought it was sad that this movie is so based in reality.
To answer your question as a born-in JW, I was afraid of both armageddon and apostasy (I would have nightmares about both, because I always had this thought that I was going to die at armageddon no matter what I did because Jehovah knew that I always had doubts). I always knew there was something wrong but was so afraid to verbalize it because I was scared of apostasy (fear of satan).
The part at the end when the main character tries to talk to her younger brother and tells him that there is no armageddon hit me like a bolt because that is exactly where I am now mentally & I want to shake people and tell them the same thing (but it is a lost cause).
I knew real versions of all of those characters in the movie (I was exposed to JW hypocracy as a young adult in the borg)
The main character's prayer at the end made me emotional too....I hope that I will not always be lost...I am just trying to be patient because I know now with no armageddon, I have time to figure out my own spirituality. (it was cool that they put the real girl in the movie at the end sitting accross the train looking at the actress playing her)
Great Flick!
CHG